MSIG vs Tokio Marine Car Insurance (2026)
Two Japanese-backed insurers — waiver of betterment vs world-class financial strength.
Choose MSIG if…
- ✓ You want waiver of betterment included
- ✓ Your car is over 3 years old
- ✓ You want key replacement coverage
- ✓ You prefer slightly lower premiums
Choose Tokio Marine if…
- ✓ Financial strength is your top priority
- ✓ You drive to Singapore or Thailand
- ✓ You own a luxury or imported vehicle
- ✓ You value global brand recognition
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Criteria | MSIG | Tokio Marine |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | ✓ 4.4 / 5.0 | 4.2 / 5.0 |
| Price | ✓ Moderate (slightly lower) | Premium tier |
| Waiver of Betterment | ✓ Included | Add-on only |
| Financial Strength | A (AM Best) | ✓ A++ (AM Best) |
| Roadside Assistance | MSIG Assist 24/7 | 24/7 Hotline |
| Panel Workshops | ✓ 800+ | 700+ |
| Claims Speed | 5 business days | 5–7 business days |
| International Coverage | Limited | ✓ SG + Thailand |
Price Comparison — Popular Models
Comprehensive estimates with 55% NCD. MSIG is typically slightly more affordable.
| Car Model | MSIG | Tokio Marine |
|---|---|---|
| Perodua Myvi 1.5 | RM980–1,200 | RM1,050–1,250 |
| Honda City 1.5 | RM1,100–1,350 | RM1,150–1,400 |
| Toyota Vios 1.5 | RM1,050–1,300 | RM1,100–1,350 |
| Honda Civic 1.5T | RM1,800–2,200 | RM1,900–2,350 |
| Toyota Corolla Cross | RM1,850–2,300 | RM1,950–2,450 |
Our Verdict
For cars over 3 years old: MSIG wins — waiver of betterment means you won't pay depreciation deductions when your older car needs parts replaced after an accident. This alone can save hundreds per claim.
For high-value or luxury vehicles: Tokio Marine's A++ financial rating and international coverage are compelling for RM150,000+ cars. Their claims process for high-value vehicles is exceptionally smooth.
For cross-border drivers: Tokio Marine is the clear winner if you drive to Singapore or Thailand regularly.
FAQs
Is MSIG or Tokio Marine better for car insurance in Malaysia?
Both are strong Japanese-backed insurers. MSIG wins on policy features — waiver of betterment, key replacement, and personal belongings coverage are included. Tokio Marine wins on financial strength (A++ AM Best vs MSIG's A). For feature-rich coverage, MSIG edges it. For financial security on high-value cars, Tokio Marine is the safer bet.
Which is cheaper — MSIG or Tokio Marine?
Both sit in the mid-to-premium tier. MSIG is typically 5–10% cheaper than Tokio Marine for standard vehicles. Tokio Marine can be more competitive for luxury or imported vehicles. Get quotes from both on Bjak using your exact car details — the difference matters more for higher-value vehicles.
What is waiver of betterment and does MSIG include it?
Waiver of betterment means your insurer pays the full cost of new parts without deducting for wear and tear on your old parts. MSIG includes this as a coverage feature, which is unusual — most insurers charge extra for it. For cars over 3 years old, this can save significant money during claims.
Does Tokio Marine offer international car coverage?
Yes — Tokio Marine's comprehensive plan extends coverage to Singapore and Thailand. This is valuable if you drive across the Causeway regularly. MSIG also offers some cross-border coverage but Tokio Marine's international network (as the world's largest P&C insurer) is stronger.
Compare Both on Bjak
Get exact quotes from MSIG, Tokio Marine, and 14 other insurers in 2 minutes.
Compare on Bjak →